Amphetamine vs Caffeine
Short answer: install Amphetamine, and it is not close in 2026. It is free, maintained, and can keep your Mac awake on triggers — per app, per schedule, per drive. Caffeine is a beloved one-click classic that has not been updated in years; on current macOS it is living on borrowed time.
Side by side
| Feature | Amphetamine | Caffeine | Notchy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free | $24.99 one-time |
| Maintained | Yes | No — untouched for years | Yes |
| Minimum macOS | macOS 10.13 | Legacy — predates Apple silicon | macOS 13 Ventura |
| Triggers | Per-app, schedule, drives, network | None — one toggle | Toggle, focus-aware |
| Sessions | Timed or indefinite, auto-end | Timed presets | Timer built in |
| Also does | Keep-awake only | Keep-awake only | Keep-awake is one of 50+ tools |
Where each one actually wins
Amphetamine wins on control
Amphetamine decides when your Mac sleeps with real logic: keep it awake while a specific app runs, while a drive is attached, during a download, on a schedule — and end the session automatically when the condition clears. Sessions can hold the system, the display, or drives independently. For anyone whose renders, uploads or servers run long, this is the difference between a tool and a toy.
Caffeine wins on simplicity
Caffeine is one click on a coffee-cup icon and nothing else to learn, ever. It did one job perfectly for a decade and asked for nothing. If your need is literally 'not while this presentation runs', its zero-configuration charm is real — you just have to accept that the original binary is ancient and unmaintained, and that maintained forks exist precisely because of that.
Where both lose
Both are single-purpose menu bar icons in a menu bar that is already full, and both answer a question — is my Mac awake? — with an icon you have to go and look at. Neither shows you a timer counting down in a place you glance at anyway, and neither does anything else for you the other 23 hours.
The third option
Notchy includes a keep-awake (Caffeine) toggle in the island, next to the Pomodoro timer it pairs with, for $24.99 once with a 7-day free trial. It is a toggle, not Amphetamine's trigger engine — if your sessions are conditional and complex, Amphetamine is the right free tool. If keep-awake is one small thing among many, it is already in your notch.
Full breakdowns: Notchy vs Amphetamine · Notchy vs Caffeine
Amphetamine vs Caffeine — FAQ
Amphetamine or Caffeine — which should I install?
Amphetamine. It is free, maintained, and adds triggers and sessions Caffeine never had. Caffeine's original app has not been updated in years, which is a real risk on current macOS.
Is Caffeine safe to use on a modern Mac?
The original Caffeine predates Apple silicon and modern macOS by years and is unmaintained. It may still run, but an unmaintained binary is a poor foundation — use Amphetamine or a maintained Caffeine fork instead.
Can Amphetamine keep only the display awake?
Yes — sessions can hold the system, the display and drives independently, and can end automatically when a trigger condition clears or a timer runs out.
Does keeping a Mac awake hurt the battery?
It spends battery by design — the screen and system stay on. Use timed sessions rather than indefinite ones on battery, and let the Mac sleep when the job finishes.
Does Notchy have a keep-awake mode?
Yes — a Caffeine-style toggle in the notch island, alongside its timers. It covers the simple case; Amphetamine remains the pick for trigger-based sessions.