BetterDisplay vs MonitorControl
Short answer: install MonitorControl if all you want is your keyboard's brightness and volume keys to work on an external monitor — it is free, open source, and done. Step up to BetterDisplay the moment you need HiDPI scaling, virtual displays, HDR or per-display colour control; nothing free goes that deep.
Side by side
| Feature | BetterDisplay | MonitorControl | Notchy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free core; Pro licence paid | Free | $24.99 one-time |
| Source | Closed source | Open source | Closed source |
| Brightness / volume (DDC) | Yes | Yes | System HUDs only |
| HiDPI scaling | Yes | No | No |
| Virtual displays | Yes | No | No |
| Also does | Deep display toolkit | Display basics only | 50+ notch tools |
Where each one actually wins
BetterDisplay wins on depth
BetterDisplay is a display engineering toolkit: unlock HiDPI resolutions on non-Retina panels, create virtual screens for streaming and sidecar-style workflows, control brightness, volume and input over DDC, manage HDR and colour profiles per display. The free core is generous; the Pro licence is for people whose multi-monitor setup is a system, not an accessory.
MonitorControl wins on focus
MonitorControl does the one thing thousands of people actually search for — make the F1/F2 brightness keys and the volume keys drive an external monitor — and stops there. Free, open source, a tiny menu bar item, no settings labyrinth. For a single external display at a desk, everything beyond that is ceremony.
Where both lose
Neither is a glanceable workspace tool: both live in the menu bar and settings windows, and neither knows about your notch, clipboard or day. BetterDisplay's depth is also its risk — you can spend an evening in its menus — while MonitorControl's community pace means new-macOS support arrives when it arrives.
The third option
Notchy does not control external displays, and if DDC brightness is what you need, MonitorControl above is the honest free answer. Notchy replaces the system HUDs your display keys trigger — volume, brightness and battery as a proper island — and adds the 50+ tools around them, for $24.99 once with a 7-day free trial.
Full breakdowns: Notchy vs BetterDisplay · Notchy vs MonitorControl
BetterDisplay vs MonitorControl — FAQ
BetterDisplay or MonitorControl — which do I need?
MonitorControl if you only want keyboard brightness and volume control for an external monitor — it is free and open source. BetterDisplay if you need HiDPI scaling, virtual displays, HDR or per-display colour control.
Is MonitorControl really free?
Yes — free and open source on GitHub. There is no paid tier.
What does BetterDisplay Pro add?
The Pro licence unlocks the advanced feature set on top of the free core — the deeper display engineering: more virtual-display and scaling control, HDR and colour management. betterdisplay.pro lists the current split.
Do they work with Apple silicon?
Yes, both support Apple silicon Macs, and both control external displays over DDC — which does depend on the monitor cooperating; some displays limit DDC control.
Can Notchy control my external monitor's brightness?
No — Notchy shows system HUDs (volume, brightness, battery) in the notch but does not send DDC commands to external displays. That is MonitorControl's and BetterDisplay's job.