ChocolateBar vs Notchy: a second row for your icons, or hiding in the notch
ChocolateBar, by independent developer Aloysius Lim, attacks the crowded menu bar differently from every hider: instead of collapsing icons away, it gives them a second row under the menu bar — click an icon there and its menu opens, full size, including the ones the notch swallows on a MacBook. It reads the bar through the Accessibility API and never asks for Screen Recording. It is $15 once with a year of updates (a 48-hour free trial, 7-day refund), and runs on macOS 12 Monterey through 15 Sequoia — its site says macOS 26 Tahoe support is still coming. Notchy hides icons the classic way, inside a $24.99 one-time notch app that runs on current macOS.
Looking for ChocolateBar itself? It lives at chocolatebar.app.
- ChocolateBar price
- $15 one-time
- ChocolateBar requires
- macOS 12 Monterey to 15 Sequoia
- Notchy price
- $24.99 one-time, 7-day free trial
Why use Notchy instead of ChocolateBar?
- Show, don't hide
Bartender-style apps (and Notchy) hide icons behind a toggle. ChocolateBar keeps every icon visible and reachable in a second row — better if you actually use those icons all day, heavier if you just want them gone.
- The notch problem, addressed directly
Icons that slide behind the camera housing are unclickable in macOS; ChocolateBar surfaces them at full size in its row. Notchy also recovers notch-swallowed icons, because the notch is its home turf.
- The macOS ceiling matters
ChocolateBar currently supports macOS 12–15, with Tahoe support 'coming soon' per its site. On macOS 26 today, it isn't an option; Notchy runs on macOS 13 through the current release.
- Where ChocolateBar is better
The second-row idea itself, a $15 price with every Mac you own covered, a 5 MB download, and no telemetry, analytics or accounts. Where Notchy pulls ahead: current-macOS support, actual hiding, and the other fifty tools in the same purchase.
Everything Notchy does, in one app
- Fluid Dynamic Island animations on the Mac notch
- Command palette (⌃⌥K) — every action one keystroke away
- Knock — double-tap a modifier key to open the notch
- AI usage tracker (Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Copilot)
- Detach any tab into a menu-bar popover
- Now Playing music controls (Apple Music & Spotify)
- Time-synced karaoke lyrics under the notch
- Mac clipboard history shelf (password-manager safe)
- Searchable clipboard — filter by text, file name, or OCR'd words
- On-device OCR — copy a screenshot, get its text (Apple Vision)
- Window snapping — drag a window to the notch to tile it
- App Launcher — pin apps to the notch, open with one tap
Show all 51Show fewer
- Text snippets — TextExpander-style pastes from the ⌘K palette
- One-tap screen capture to clipboard + shelf
- Color eyedropper — sample any pixel, hex auto-copied
- System-wide mic mute for every meeting app at once
- Keystroke HUD for demos & screencasts (secure-input safe)
- Keyboard cleaning lock with countdown island (⌘⎋ unlocks)
- Menu-bar icon hiding — Bartender-style separator & chevron
- Live CPU / memory / network stats flyout
- Custom islands through the local developer API (off by default)
- iPhone-style call island — Answer/Decline FaceTime on the notch
- Notch Terminal — real VT100/xterm shell in a PTY, its own tab
- Camera Guard — alert (or block) when any app opens your camera
- Caps Lock HUD — brief island on every toggle
- Full Charge island with adjustable threshold + low-battery sound
- Alt HUD styles — edge-pinned bar or circular gauge off the notch
- Audio-reactive Now Playing visualizer (real FFT of system audio)
- Custom closed-notch idle animation — drop in your own Lottie JSON
- Drag-and-drop file drop shelf — persists across relaunches
- Zip & unzip files right from the shelf
- Image converter (HEIC, PNG, JPEG, TIFF, PDF) + video → GIF
- Run Apple Shortcuts with one tap
- Screenshots auto-staged on the shelf, ready to drag
- Download finished alerts with Reveal in Finder
- USB drive mount island with one-tap Eject
- Apple Reminders quick capture & due list
- macOS Pomodoro notch timer & stopwatch — streaks + 7-day chart
- Resizable expanded panel (width & height, live preview)
- System HUDs (volume, brightness, battery)
- Audio output switcher (speakers, AirPods, monitor)
- AirPods connection manager & battery
- Magic Mouse, Keyboard & Trackpad battery + low-battery alerts
- Quick notes & Calendar widgets
- Camera Mirror (check your appearance)
- Keep Awake (caffeine toggle)
- Teleprompter (Cuely) for Zoom calls
- Focus-aware alerts & native haptic feedback
- Lock screen widgets & hide-the-notch mode
- 134 languages, fully localized
- Native SwiftUI, tuned for Apple silicon
The honest verdict on ChocolateBar
ChocolateBar is the cleverest answer to a crowded menu bar on macOS 12–15: don't hide the icons, give them a second row — $15, every Mac you own. On macOS 26, or if you want the icons gone rather than relocated, Notchy's hiding inside the full island is the working option today.
ChocolateBar alternative — FAQ
Is ChocolateBar free?
No. It is $15 one-time with a year of updates, a 48-hour free trial with no card and a 7-day refund (a launch code has offered $12 to a limited number of buyers). Notchy is $24.99 once after a 7-day free trial.
What Mac does ChocolateBar need?
macOS 12 Monterey through 15 Sequoia, on Apple silicon or Intel — macOS 26 Tahoe support is listed as coming soon on chocolatebar.app, and macOS 27 is not supported. Notchy runs on macOS 13 Ventura through the current macOS.
Does ChocolateBar hide menu bar icons?
It can hide crowded icons, but its signature is the opposite: a second row under the menu bar where every icon stays visible and clickable. Notchy hides icons behind a separator and chevron, Bartender-style.
Does ChocolateBar need Screen Recording permission?
No — it works through the Accessibility API only, which its site makes a point of. Notchy asks for the permissions each of its features needs, and its icon hiding needs Accessibility too.
Can ChocolateBar show icons hidden behind the notch?
Yes — recovering icons the notch makes unreachable is one of its headline uses. Notchy surfaces them as well, from inside the notch itself.